Culture, principles, values & judgement
At Pagelove, we're in it for the long haul to build something for the long term. And to do that requires judgement. Conscious, active judgement, grounded firmly in fundamental principles. This will hopefully explain the culture we're trying to create, and how we're trying to create it.
Before I get stuck in to this topic, it's important to credit Steve Tuck, Bryan Cantrill and everybody at Oxide, from whom I've adopted the distinction between principles and values, and the principles themselves. Steve, Bryan and I all worked at Joyent many moons ago now, and I suspect that at least some of the forces that influenced them had a similar influence upon me. I've long admired what Steve and Bryan have done with Oxide's principles and values, but my thoughts on the subject have evolved slightly differently from their approach, and this post explains how.
I lived through technology companies changing from something I venerated – the Silicon Valley of Atari, Xerox PARC, Apple, Sun and SGI – to something I felt that I merely survived. From Google’s “don’t be evil” to Facebook’s “move fast and break things”, ultimately to Uber’s “always be hustlin’”. Each progressively described their intended culture in a way that could increasingly be used to excuse poor behaviour.
Fundamentally culture is about behaviour. I’ve often quipped that a culture of a company is best defined by the worst behaviours of its best performers. Normally I employ it as a critique of a list of values which often get written down as some sort of corporate response to terrible behaviour, rather than fixing the behaviour itself. Which is to say, what is tolerated is de facto acceptable, no matter what has been presented as an organisation’s culture.
So to have a good culture, it is insufficient to simply write down a list of behaviours. It’s important to consider how those behaviours come about, and how you steer the organisation to a set of better behaviours. And that means first establishing what is unacceptable: bigotry, disrespect, dishonesty, duplicity and corruption for example. Any display of them should not be tolerated, they are all morally wrong. There are almost certainly other morally wrong behaviours, so rather than expressing just a list of things that we will not tolerate, it’s more effective to find a set of behaviours that are required.
My insistence then on fundamental principles is that they express the inverse of the behaviours I’m not willing to tolerate hence integrity, honesty, decency. These are principles, and they are unbending and uncompromising.
Acting in any way that diminishes one’s integrity, honesty, or decency betrays those principles and is therefore unacceptable, and if we ever find ourselves in circumstances where we would knowingly do so, we should immediately stop what we are doing. Principles provide a hard brake on our actions, and they prevent us from acting in a manner that is morally wrong.
However, our actions are guided by more than just principles. Even the decision to act or not is guided by more than a principle. The decisions that lead us to act in one way over another way are influenced by the material considerations we have: what the relevant factors & constraints are, and what values – quantitative or qualitative – we hope to achieve with the outcome: the set of consequences that result from a course of action.
Values are the desirable qualities of the action and the properties we may consider important in evaluating the consequences.
Rigour & pragmatism. Conviction & empiricism. Candour & tact. Thriftiness & urgency. Each of these is valuable in their own right, in the right circumstances, but any taken to an extreme would be problematic. Because we often select one at the expense of another, they are inherently in tension. That isn’t to say these are always in tension. Or even that they are only in tension with the other. They might be in tension with any other value, and it is important to acknowledge it when they are.
For example, a manager may be conducting a discussion about the performance of a team member with that individual. In such a scenario, a manager should value candour, as there is little purpose in having such a discussion if they aren’t going to be candid. But that value doesn’t mean the manager should act without decency towards the individual. They should be prepared to discuss candidly how the individual’s performance is evaluated, but to do so in a manner that treats the individual with decency.
Decency is a principle. The manager must treat people with dignity and respect. Candour is a value. The manager may choose how forthcoming and direct to be. Tact is a value in tension with candour. The individual’s feelings and how they might receive the feedback should be considered.
While candour and tact often exist in tension, neither provides an excuse to sacrifice the principles of honesty or decency. Values function as preferences that steer us toward desired outcomes, shaping our decision-making as we attempt to maximize one over another. Principles, on the other hand, establish firm boundaries that constrain our actions.
Good judgement requires considering the material circumstances, weighing the values we seek in an outcome, within the constraints imposed by our principles. Sometimes our judgement can be poor despite our best efforts, but if we have actually practiced what is required for judgement, then expressing the reasoning behind it should at least be possible. Not from first principles, not from atoms up. Just the basis for the decision.
The only time it should ever be truly difficult is if there is an absence of judgement, and an absence of judgement demonstrates a failure to think. And the failure to think is something I actively want to prevent.
As humans, we often behave as though we have two minds – one conscious, aware, and reflective. The other deep and primeval. It's reactive, and reactionary, and keeps us alive when the building is burning down around us. It protects us from danger and responds quickly to the unknown or different. It is unconscious, and in non-survival situations, it often lets us down.
If we’re not careful it sneaks its fear into our everyday lives. It’s where selfishness, greed, bigotry and prejudice slip in. It’s what happens when we value speed and instinct above all else. I suspect valuing speed and instinct above all else had a hand in turning companies that may have started with noble goals into companies that acted in ways they'd not have wanted at the outset.
I’m not interested in Pagelove being just a company that makes a product. I’m here for the long haul to build something for the long term. And to do that requires judgement. Conscious, active judgement. Grounded in uncompromising fundamental principles.
Something that isn’t merely not evil. Something that is good.
That is the culture we're trying to build.